Opening post by Past100 · #1
A trader came through with a version of this I had not heard, which is the excuse I am using for bringing it up again.
The question, put plainly: whether Coldhands is who everyone says he is. I think it will turn out to be simpler and sadder than the songs have it.
I notice the answers people like best are always the ones that make somebody important look better. That is not proof of anything, but it is a pattern.
Anyone who is certain about this has not thought about it long enough.